Fiduciary Misperceptions

The Misperception of Fiduciary Risk and Active Management in DC Plans: A Legal Perspective

Executive Summary

Plan sponsors today have unprecedented options available to them when making investment selection decisions for their plans. Among those options is a wide array of actively managed investment strategies. These strategies provide participants a diversity of choice and the opportunity to benefit from excess returns above a benchmark, which can have a significant impact on portfolio value over longer time horizons due to the power of compounding. At the same time, plan sponsors face increasingly complex fiduciary requirements, as well as pressure to provide an optimal plan experience for participants at a reasonable cost. Making investment selection decisions under these conditions can prove challenging. This white paper aims to help fiduciaries navigate the waters of plan investment selection and monitoring processes by:

  • Decoding the legal standards that apply to fiduciaries who are responsible for choosing investment options for their plans.
  • Identifying some guiding principles drawn from legal authorities that may assist fiduciaries assessing investment strategies such as active and passive as part of a plan lineup.
  • Emphasizing the importance of process as the most important factor in fiduciary decision-making.

Decoding ERISA’s Fiduciary Standards

ERISA holds plan fiduciaries to certain standards of care that the courts regard as the highest standards known to law, namely:
 

  • Fiduciaries owe a duty of loyalty1 to plan participants and beneficiaries. This means that the fiduciaries must act solely in the interests of the plan’s participants and beneficiaries and for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and paying only reasonable plan expenses. This standard is often is referred to as the "exclusive benefit rule."
  • Fiduciaries owe a duty of care2 to plan participants and beneficiaries. This means that when the fiduciaries act for the plan, they must act “with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use in the conduct of a like character and with like aims.” This standard is known as the "prudent person rule."
  • Fiduciaries also must act consistent with the documents3 that govern the plan and must diversify4 the plan’s investments so as to minimize the risk of investment losses.
     
When it comes to a plan’s investments, most defined contribution plans are set up so that the participants themselves can decide how to invest their plan accounts. Even so, plan fiduciaries do have the responsibility to select and to monitor the investment options that will be made available to participants. Meeting these responsibilities requires an informed and thorough evaluation of both the needs of their plan and the options available in the marketplace. Here, the focus is on the inputs to the fiduciary’s decision-making, and not on the investment outcomes achieved. In other words, employing a good investment selection and monitoring process is a key to meeting fiduciary obligations.
 
A good fiduciary investment selection process may include:
 
  • Understanding the documents that govern the plan, which may set forth investment objectives or mandates for the plan. Remember, following the plan documents is a key fiduciary obligation.
  • Meeting regularly to discuss and review the plan’s investment options. Again, the focus here is on process. It is important to have a decision-making process that is thorough, consistently applied, and documented.
  • Considering key attributes of the investment options (such as performance, expenses, and volatility) when considering available options and monitoring those investments chosen for the plan.

Fiduciary Misperceptions

Read the Full Article

The Misperception of Fiduciary Risk
In the complex and litigation-prone world defined contribution plans occupy, it is important to underline what the real focal points for fiduciaries should be.

1 ERISA § 404(a)(1)(A), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(A).
2 ERISA § 404(a)(1)(B), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(B).
3 ERISA § 404(a)(1)(D), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(D).
4 ERISA § 404(a)(1)(C), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(C)

This paper is sponsored by T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. Contents of this paper are for informational purposes only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. The analysis and conclusions are solely those of the author.

Dismiss
Tap to dismiss

Subscriptions/Watch list

Unsubscribe All
OK

Manage your watched Funds and Insights subscriptions here.

OK

Change Details

Congratulations! You are now registered.

Begin watching and receiving email updates for:

Ok

Sign in to manage your subscriptions and watch list.

Register

Download

Latest Date Range
Download Cancel

Institutional Content

I have read and agree to the terms and conditions
Confirm Cancel

This content is restricted for Institutional Investors use only. We were not able to validate your status as an Institutional Investor with the information you provided at registration.

Please contact the T. Rowe Price Team with questions or to revise your status.

1-800-564-6958

You will need to accept the Terms & Conditions again.

Ok

You have updated your email address.

An activation email has been sent to your new email address from T. Rowe Price.

Please click on the activation link in order to receive email updates.

Ok

You have an existing account

Click OK to view your subscriptions and watch list.

OK

Confirm Cancel